A record of my emails on the driveway S9 at Vistana Heights
Most of my emails to all concerned on the retaining wall were listed HERE.
This is a record of most of my emails on the driveway.
1.
To:topwiracorporation@yahoo.com
Sat, 14 May 2022 at 05:44
Dear Ms. Monica,
I refer to our discussion on 12.5.2022 at Puncak Vistana.
I told you that my car (Proton Wira) when reversing into my son's house (number 15) had the front bumper scraped against the road.
You retorted that it was because my car was low.
I found that answer rather ridiculous as that is a standard car. The car was unable to go up without scraping the bumper because the driveway is too steep.
I asked if you had a solution to this problem and you said that I could expand the road entrance like that done by the house owner at number 19.
Pray tell me why this expansion should be at the expense of the house buyer when the problem is one due to construction fault.
I then asked you if you would permit the house to be sold. You replied that you would grant permission for the house to be sold only if the LAD compensation is agreed to be reduced.
I replied that this response from you is unacceptable to me. I don't understand why a discount on the LAD should be given before you consent for the house sale.
I then requested you to think further on this matter and revert.
Looking forward to hearing from you.
Attached, please find a photo of my car on the driveway.
2.
Extract of email to architect:
To:arkiteklys@gmail.com
1 Aug 2022 at 10:11
Dear Mr.Jonathan Lee,
We spoke on 22.7.22 where I requested information on 3 matters pertaining to Vistana Heights.
3. The driveway is too steep for a Proton Waja to drive up to the car porch.
Who is responsible for this?
Is there a maximum gradient for the driveway that an architect/ engineer should adhere to?
3.
Extract of email to Institute of Engineers Malaysia
To:iemsabah@gmail.com
Fri, 19 Aug 2022 at 14:28
Dear sir,
I have been trying to resolve a few questions in my mind on problems encountered on the purchase of a house by my son, Faisal Luqman at Vistana Heights.
The developer of Vistana Heights does not cooperate and does not answer questions raised.
I spoke with the architect Mr.Jonathan Lee of Arkitek LYS on 22.7.2022 who said that he will revert but did not. I emailed him on 1.8.2022 and he has yet to respond.
3. The driveway is too steep for a Proton Waja to drive up to the car porch.
Who is responsible for this?
Is there a maximum gradient for the driveway that an architect/ engineer should adhere to?
Email to Zaidun Leeng on 8.8.2022 copied:
Sir, a notice has been issued to owners of the units/houses in Vistana Heights that no renovation or repairs may be done outside the fence of the unit. If we cannot drive a standard car up the driveway what are the alternatives we have.
I believe it is not appropriate for unit/house owners to have to fork out money to repair driveways constructed by the developer which cannot be accessed by standard cars.
4
Reply from Zaidun Leeng – extract:
From:zaidunleengsabah@yahoo.com
To:luqman michel
Tue, 23 Aug 2022 at 15:46
Dear Mr. Luqman,
As for the road issue, we have checked that the design was in order and was approved by council as well as inspected by authority before O.C. At the mean time, we have also spoken to the developer and raised your concern to them, and they will look into the matters more closely.
5.
Extracts of email to Zaidun Leeng.
To:Zaidun Leeng
Cc:pamsabah@gmail.com,iemsabah@gmail.com
Wed, 24 Aug 2022 at 06:47
Dear Mr. Tan,
Thank you for your response dated 23.8.2022 to my email dated 8.8.2022.
You say that the design of the driveway is in order and inspected and approved by Council.
I refer to point 3 of my email to you dated 8.8.2022 which I now copy below for your convenience.
3. The driveway is too steep for a Proton Waja to drive up to the car porch.
Who is responsible for this?
Is there a maximum gradient for the driveway that an architect/ engineer should adhere to?
I would appreciate a response from you as soon as possible so that I may take appropriate action.
You have not answered my questions above and I would be grateful for specific answers before bringing this matter up to the mayor.
Mr.Tan, you said that the design is in order, please confirm if the driveway was constructed by the developers according to your design.
You state, in your email, that you have spoken to the developer. I too have spoken to the developer on this matter on 12.5.2022 and written an email to them on 14.5.2022, complete with a photograph of my Proton Waja on the driveway, which has yet to be responded to.
6.
Extract of email to Mr. Saiman Angak of DBKK.
To:saiman.angak@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Mon, 29 Aug 2022 at 05:12
Dear Enc. Saiman,
The driveway leading into the house from the approach road 'Puncak Vistana 1' is too steep for a standard car, Proton Waja to access.
I spoke with the JKR engineer Ms. Nellysa who inspected the access road and informed me she has briefed you on the matter and that you will contact me.
She informed me that the 'Puncak Vistana 1' road is not under the jurisdiction of JKR.
Sir, I would be grateful if you could let me know what course of action you are taking on this matter.
I have been going to the house for 2 years without being able to drive up to the car porch.
I have written to the Engineers and the architect concerned. The engineer has referred the matter to the developer and the architect has not replied.
I have also written to IEM and PAM who have yet to respond.
I hope the buck will stop here and you will resolve this matter.
Attached, please find a photo of my Waja on the driveway. If I drive a little further up the bumper will be broken.
7.
Extract of email to PAM Sabah.
To:info@pam.org.my
Cc:pamsabah@gmail.com,arkiteklys@gmail.com
Mon, 29 Aug 2022 at 05:38
Dear Sirs,
Sir, are architects not responsible for design faults? Are architects not responsible for wrong construction of driveways that are not in accordance with original drawings?
8.
Extract of emails to Mayor
To:mayor@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Tue, 6 Sept 2022 at 10:47
Dear Ms. Florence,
Further to our telephone conversation a few minutes ago I copy herewith the email I had sent to Enc. Saiman Angak. He has yet to reply to my email.
Please also refer to my blog post on this matter with a relevant video of the driveway reconstructed by an owner opposite unit no. 15 mentioned in my email below. (Blog post found at https://luqmanmusings.blogspot.com/2022/08/vistana-heights-ordeals-of-house-owners_26.html
A few of us - house owners- are also concerned with no retention walls being built at the back of some of the units.
A few house owners would like to make an appointment with the mayor to help with our predicament.
9.
Extracts of email to Zaidun Leeng
To:zaidunleengsabah@yahoo.com
Mon, 26 Sept 2022 at 13:36
Dear Sir,
Not getting a satisfactory response from Mrs. Lee, I wrote to the engineers on this matter on 5.1.2021.
For Mrs. Lee to say that I had not complained to her before the expiry of the defect liability period is misrepresentation.
Mrs. Lee had said that Topwira Corporation Sdn Bhd has been sued by some of the house buyers and that she will wait for the outcome of the court case before acting on my complaints.
On 12.5.2022 I spoke about the driveway being too steep for my Proton Wira to access it. She retorted that my car is too low. I then wrote an email to Topwira Corporation Sdn. Bhd. which has yet to be responded to.
Subsequently, I discussed this matter with Ms. Jessie Lee who said that the management team is discussing this matter and that she will revert. I have not heard from her or Mrs. Monica Lee on this matter since.
10.
Extracts of email to Enc. Durie of DBKK
To:Durie.Juneh@sabah.gov.my
Tue, 4 Oct 2022 at 05:25
Dear Enc. Durie,
Thank you for your visit to Vistana Heights yesterday morning.
Below is the email I wrote to Enc. Saiman Angak on 29.8.2022 which has yet to be replied by him.
11.*
To:Durie.Juneh@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Tue, 4 Oct 2022 at 11:43
Dear Enc. Durie,
I went to 4th floor to either purchase or view the development plan for Vistana Heights. I was instructed by Puan Tantinny Fung via her staff that I am not allowed to even view the Development plan as the public may misuse the information on the plan.
I was directed to complain to the complaint section on the first floor. That is where I met Enc. Julian, who asked me relevant questions and then telephoned you.
12.*
To:tantinny.fung@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Cc:dony.johanes@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Thu, 6 Oct 2022 at 11:08
Dear Puan Tantinny Fung,
The development plan attached to the S&P agreement below is not clear and I would like to have a copy of the development plan for a number of reasons.
I would be grateful if you will kindly extend me a copy of the development plan.
Let me know when I may collect the same.
13.*
To:JPB, DBKK / Dony J.G. Sinit
Thu, 6 Oct 2022 at 17:24
Dear Enc. Dony,
Thank you very much for your assistance.
I telephoned the Architect, Mr. Jonathan Lee of Arkitek LYS, at the suggestion of one of your colleagues. He refused to extend me a copy of the Development Plan and asked me to get it from the developer.
The developer, on the other hand, does not reply to any of the emails sent.
14.
To:Julian.Joseph@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Cc:topwiracorporation@yahoo.com,arkiteklys@gmail.com,zlsemsb@gmail.com,zaidunleengsabah@yahoo.com,pamsabah@gmail.com
Mon, 10 Oct 2022 at 14:43
Dear Sir,
On 4.10.2022, I met with you in your office and you asked me to write my complaints and email you. Please find attached:
i. Complaints on house no 15 (S9) specifically and construction at Vistana Heights, Ira Manis, in general.
ii. Details of emails mentioned in i. above.
The occupation certificate issued by DBKK on 2.10.2019 states that the project was approved ‘upon confirmation of the Consultants that the buildings and infrastructure works has been completed in accordance with their design and supervision as per approved/endorsed plan.’
My question to the professionals involved in the project on whether the completed work is consistent with the design as per the approved plan has never been answered.
I believe the original plan submitted to DBKK has been approved by DBKK but is the completed work consistent with the original endorsed plan?
I believe the professionals should have monitored the work at the construction site and checked that the work was carried out according to the drawings submitted to DBKK.
Did the professionals who prepared applications for statutory approval state the deviation, if any, from the original endorsed plan?
15.
Reply from Enc. Julian of DBKK
From:julian.joseph@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
To:kalvin@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,tantinny.fung@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,jack@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,saiman.angak@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,alexcius.likid@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,durie.juneh@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,dony.johanes@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,lilitia@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,beddu.ahmad@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,raynerricky.sedomon@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Cc:luqmanmichel,manaf@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,zainuddin.abdgoyoh@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,esther.chongchiufung@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,salmah.batin@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,gloriediana.joseph@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,elezebeth.yadon@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,carey.paulin@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,salvia.yusop@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Tue, 11 Oct 2022 at 15:12
Selamat petang
Terima kasih kerana menghubungi Jabatan Pengaduan Dan Perhubungan Awam ( JPPA ), DBKK. Untuk makluman, aduan ini telah dimajukan kepada pegawai yang bertanggungjawab untuk tindakan jabatan bertindak. Sekali lagi diucapkan ribuan terima kasih kerana menghubungi Jabatan Pengaduan Dan Perhubungan Awam dalam usaha membantu menambahbaik kualiti perkhidmatan bandaraya Kota Kinabalu.
Untuk makluman tuan/puan pihak JPPA telah menerima emal berhubung perkara dia atas untuk perhatian, pemeriksaan dan tindakan lanjut .
Mohon dapat membantu aduan seperti yang di dimajukan oleh pengadu yang telah diemail ke Laman Web Rasmi DBKK dibawah. Kerjasama tuan/ puan dalam perkara ini diucapkan berbanyak terima kasih.
16.*
My letter to mayor
13.10.2022
Dear Datuk,
Re: Original Development plan for development of Vistana Heights Phase 1
I would be grateful if I may purchase a copy of the original development plan submitted to DBKK as the development plan on the S&P agreement is not clear.
I understand that the construction of the infrastructure deviates from the original submission. This has resulted in the driveway to house no 15 and several other houses too steep for standard cars to drive up to the car porch.
I would be grateful if you could also confirm if a retention wall was designed behind the houses on the left hand side of the Puncak Vistana 1 road in the original plan. There is a steep fall of more than 20 feet behind the perimeter fence.
Attached, please find a copy of the S&P Agreement.
17.
Reply from PAM
Professional Practice Committee
From:practice@pam.org.my
To:luqmanm2002@yahoo.co.uk
Fri, 14 Oct 2022 at 10:52
Dear Mr. Luqman,
We refer to your query as received on the 29th August 2022 and would reply as follows:
3. We have also been led to understand that there is a current, legal dispute between yourself and the Developer. Apart from not being able to comment based on the information we have received, we hope you understand that we are also unable to add any further advice lest it may be misconstrued as interference within the above-mentioned dispute.
18.
Email to LPPB
To:info@lppb.gov.my,aduan.lppb@sabah.gov.my
Sun, 30 Oct 2022 at 04:54
Dear Sir,
I am now writing to you before going to the Local Housing Minister and to the press.
i. The driveway leading to my house and many other houses is too steep for standard cars. I have been unable to drive up to my car porch since OC was issued in October 2019.
v. Many questions to DBKK, including how OC was issued when many of the house owners are unable to drive up the driveway, have not been answered.
vi. We have discovered that the work done is not in accordance with the approved development plan.
Despite several emails and reminders, the above problems have not been resolved by the developer or the professionals concerned.
A few of the house owners and I would be grateful if you could arrange a meeting immediately between your officers, the developer and the professionals to amicably resolve the problems.
19.*
Email to LPPB
To:Rosemary.Ahping@Sabah.gov.my
Cc:Della.Sinidol@Sabah.gov.my
Mon, 31 Oct 2022 at 15:25
Dear Ma’am,
I met up with your Puan Zaliezah Raskan this morning and explained to her my concern about the construction of Vistana Heights Phase 1. She said that she is aware of my email to aduan.lppb@sabah.gov.my.
I have been informed by officers at DBKK that the only approved Development Plan in their office is the DP dated 27.11.2006 that was handed over to me. The no Siri is DP/002/11.06.
I was informed by your Puan Zaliezah Raskan at this morning’s meeting that she also knows of only the DP dated 27.11.2006.
The above DP is different from the DP attached to the S&P agreement provided to my son Faisal Luqman on the purchase of house no. 15 (S9).
The DP shows the road at 100’ and the car porch to be 101’. However, the existing road and car porch are not consistent with the approved DP.
There is no retaining wall constructed behind houses No S10 downwards to house no S1. Kindly confirm if there was a retention wall designed or otherwise. A steep fall of more than 20 feet without a retention wall looks precarious.
I, on behalf of some of the owners of houses at Vistana Height Phase 1 would like to have a meeting among you, Topwira Corporation Snd. Bhd, the management of Vistana Heights and any other concerned parties, as soon as possible.
Attached, please find emails to Topwira Corporation Sdn. Bhd and the management company.
20.*
Email to Puan Tantinny fung of DBKK
To:tantinny.fung@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Cc:Rosemary.Ahping@Sabah.gov.my,Della.Sinidol@Sabah.gov.my
Tue, 1 Nov 2022 at 05:32
Dear Puan Tantinny Fung,
On 28.10.2022, I obtained the Approved Development Plan for Vistana Heights, DP No: DP/002/11.06 dated 29.11.2006, from your office.
I was informed by your officers that there is no subsequent/ amended DP to the one given to me.
On 31.10.2022, I was also informed by an officer, Puan Zaliezah Raskan, of LPPB that the DP above is the only one approved by DBKK that is in her possession.
I would be grateful if you could confirm that the above is the only DP and that there is no amended DP. This is important as the road level and the car porch level for my house no 15 (S9) on the approved DP are 100' and 101' respectively.
The as-built gradient of the driveway is not consistent with that of the DP.
21.
Email to LPPB
To:Rosemary.Ahping@Sabah.gov.my
Cc:Della.Sinidol@Sabah.gov.my
Tue, 15 Nov 2022 at 09:57
Dear Ma'am,
I refer to my email dated 31.10.2022 and especially the following paragraph:
I, on behalf of some of the owners of houses at Vistana Height Phase 1 would like to have a meeting among you, Topwira Corporation Sdn. Bhd, the management of Vistana Heights and any other concerned parties, as soon as possible.
I have been talking and writing to the developer's directors since December 2020. I had then tried in vain to discuss matters with the engineers and architect. The engineers and the architect have consistently asked me to deal with the developer. I then approached and discussed matters with DBKK officers and they too have directed me to the developer. It was then that a few of the house owners and I decided to contact LPPB.
Ma'am, we hope the buck stops here and will not necessitate us to escalate this matter.
We request you to please organise a meeting with the developer and the professionals involved in the project within one week from your meeting on 17.11.2022.
22.
To:info@lppb.gov.my
Wed, 23 Nov 2022 at 14:05
Dear Mr. Mohamed Andy Osman,
RE: Meeting with Topwira Corporation dated 16.11.2022
I refer to your letter captioned above dated 23.11.2022.
On behalf of the 3 other residents who met Puan Della Sinidol in the LPPB office on 3.11.2022, I thank you for your efforts in trying to sort out the problems faced by the residents of Vistana Heights Phase 1.
Mr. George Sheh, as suggested by you, has messaged Ms. Jessie Lee of Topwira to arrange a meeting among the residents and developer together with the developer’s consultants.
At the meeting with Puan Della we requested the presence of LPPB’s representative and I hope to see you present at the meeting as LPPB is the land owner.
23.
Email to LPPB
To:info@lppb.gov.my
Wed, 23 Nov 2022 at 15:37
Dear Puan Rosemary Ah Ping,
I have been unable to drive my car up to my son's car porch at Vistana Heights.
I would like to settle this matter amicably and renovate the house asap.
24.
Email to Audit Department
luqman michel
From:luqmanm2002@yahoo.co.uk
To:nasri@audit.gov.my
Cc:halimuddin@audit.gov.my,azizahdaud@audit.gov.my,jimmy@audit.gov.my,asmah@audit.gov.my
Thu, 24 Nov 2022 at 04:34
Dear Enc. Nasri,
I am not quite sure what your role is in housing development but your vehicles were seen at Vistana Heights when Topwira Corporation Sdn. Bhd. was announced as winding up.
Phase 1 of Vistana Heights was completed and OC was obtained in October 2019. Keys were handed over to me for a house (S9) purchased by my son, Faisal Luqman.
Request for a meeting with LPPB, the house owners, the developer and their consultants have yet to occur.
I have been unable to move into my house since receiving the keys in December 2019 because the driveway is too steep.
I request you look into my complaints as well as other owners' complaints before the developer is allowed to commence phase 2.
25.
Email to YB Datuk Masidi Manjun
To:mlgh@sabah.gov.my
Cc:Rosemary.Ahping@Sabah.gov.my,Della.Sinidol@Sabah.gov.my,julian.joseph@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Sun, 27 Nov 2022 at 06:13
Dear YB Datuk Masidi Manjun,
A number of houses have steep driveways where standard Malaysian cars cannot be driven up to the car porch.
Since cars could not go up the driveway, two house owners widened the driveway and were still unable to drive their cars up to the car porch. They then tore up the driveway and rebuilt it and extended it by 2 to 3 feet onto the road. This is dangerous to other road users. The developer had complained to DBKK about the driveway extensions. DBKK engineers visited the site but have not done anything about the extended driveways.
I complained to the developer about not being able to drive up the driveway of Faisal’s house. When no response came from them, I wrote to the engineers and the architect and they asked me to refer the matter to the developer. Similarly, DBKK officers who visited the site said that this should be undertaken by the developer but there has still been no repair to the road from which the driveway extends. I reported this matter to LPPB, the joint venture developers of this housing project, but they have also not done anything to appease us.
Datuk, I beg you to look into this problem immediately.
As it is, the road leading to the houses is dangerous to drive. What more if more of the house owners decide to extend their driveways like that done by the two house owners.
There should be a solution to this mess up by the developer and the authorities.
26.
Email to Datuk Jamalu Nais - - Permanent Secretary at Housing
Wed, 30 Nov 2022 at 09:53
Same content as that sent to Datuk Masidi.
27.
Email to Datuk Mohd Sofian Alfian Nair
Date: Wed, Dec 7, 2022 at 10:09 AM
Subject: Re: Datuk Mohd Sofian Alfian Nair - Vistana Heights complaints
To: janette.motijol@sabah.gov.my <janette.motijol@sabah.gov.my>
Dear Puan Janette,
When I sent you the attached letter to YB Datuk Masidi Manjun, you said that I had sent it to the wrong Permanent Secretary.
In a way you are correct.
However, I saw the following on a website this morning:
Four ex-officio members, who shall be the Permanent Secretary of the
Ministry of Local Government and Housing, the Permanent Secretary of
the Ministry of Finance, the Permanent Secretary of the Ministry of
Communications and Works and the Director of the Town and Country
Planning Department;
I, therefore, request you to please pass it on to your Boss for his attention. I believe he should be informed.
28.
Email to Datuk Roland Chia
To:drolandchia@sogip.com.my,drolandchia@gmail.com
Fri, 23 Dec 2022 at 11:34
Dear Dr. Roland Chia Ming Shen,
I would be grateful if you would kindly pass the attachment to YB. Datuk Hajiji.
I sincerely hope that the buck will stop here.
All former attempts have failed.
29.
Email to Mr. Stanley Chong
To:Stanley.Chong@sabah.gov.my
Cc:Mudznah.Yusop@sabah.gov.my
Tue, 3 Jan 2023 at 10:31
Dear Sir,
Mr. Chong, the amended development plan is fabricated and so is the as-built survey.
I have been unable to drive up the steep driveway to the porch. My emails to DBKK officers and LPPB officers have not been responded to.
I would be grateful if you could let me know on what basis you approved the Amended Development Plan.
30.
Email from Mr. Stanley Chong
STANLEY CHONG HON CHUNG
From:stanley.chong@sabah.gov.my
To:luqman michel
Cc:HJH MUDZNAH HAJI YUSOP @ MUDJNAH
Fri, 6 Jan 2023 at 14:21
Hi Luqman,
Thanks for your email. I take note on the subject matter and your email pertaining to your remarks on the fraudulent development plan approval.
I will ask DBKK to provide all documents pertaining to the approval of Vistana Heights Development Plan, OC and also documents pertaining to the developer license. Once I get the document ready, I will call a meeting as soon as possible and I will invite you to attend the meeting together with the developer and its consultants, DBKK, KKTP Housing Controller, PAM and Lembaga Juruukur Sabah to discuss and investigate further if the amended development plan is really fabricated and fraudulent as you mentioned in your email.
31.
Email to Ronny cham & Co and copied to Mr.stanley Chong, LPPB and Topwira.
To:legal@ronnychamco.com
Cc:aduan.lppb@sabah.gov.my,stanley.chong@sabah.gov.my,topwiracorporation@yahoo.com,Rosemary.Ahping@Sabah.gov.my
Fri, 20 Jan 2023 at 11:49
Dear Mr. Cham Nyit Shin,
I refer to your letter ref: 10310.22.11.25.01.r.ok dated 25.11.2022.
You said that you are acting on behalf of Rosemary Ahping and Della E. Sinidol of Lembaga Pembangunan Perumahan Dan Bandar (LPPB). I have written to Rosemary and asked her if she had instructed you to act on behalf of LPPB and I have had no response. The legal officer at LPPB said that you are not on the panel of lawyers of LPPB. Please confirm if you did receive written instruction from Rosemary to act for LPPB.
You further mentioned that ‘the development of the said Taman Puncak Vistana was under the jurisdiction of the Housing Controller Sabah of the Housing and Local Government Ministry, and in accordance with the Housing Development (Control and Licensing) Enactment 1978 and the rules made thereunder’. Could you please let me know where you got this notion from?
You ought to know that many of the rules had been broken by the developer, Topwira Corporation Sdn Bhd. Among the many rules broken are the few mentioned below:
First Schedule
i. h) Plans approved and cannot be changed
The plans for the Project and the property has been duly approved by the Appropriate Authority and no alterations to the approved plans shall be made or carried out except as may be required by the Appropriate Authority.
Mr. Cham, the original development plan was approved by the approving authorities (DBKK). Were the alterations made instructed by the Appropriate Authorities?
ii. (i) Good workmanlike manner in accordance with plans and specifications
The property shall be constructed in a good workmanlike manner in accordance with the specifications and plans approved by the Appropriate Authority and agreed to by and between the Purchaser and the Developer. No change thereto or deviation therefrom shall be made without the consent in writing of the Purchaser except as may be required by the Appropriate Authority…
Mr. Cham, the rules above clearly state that no change or deviation from the approved plans shall be made without the consent in writing of the purchaser. Have you seen the consent from the purchasers?
Good workmanlike manner in accordance with plans and specifications will include driveways that are accessible by standard Malaysian cars. However, this is not the case with the development at Puncak Vistana. What is your view?
Mr. Cham Nyit Shin, with the above and more infringement how dare you have the audacity to state that the development of Taman Puncak Vistana is in accordance with the Housing Development (Control and Licensing) Enactment 1978 and the rules made thereunder?
The surveyor and architect of Topwira Corporation Sdn. Bhd, have fabricated the as-built survey drawings and the amended development plans to obtain the occupancy certificate. What is your stand on this?
32.
To:legal@ronnychamco.com
Cc:aduan.lppb@sabah.gov.my,topwiracorporation@yahoo.com
Mon, 30 Jan 2023 at 14:16
Dear Mr. Ronny Cham,
I refer to my email to you dated 20.1.2023 and your response dated 26.1.2023.
You said that you have no further instructions from Rosemary Ahping and Della Sinidol.
You have not answered as to whether both the above named had indeed instructed you in the first place.
Further questions on the above are:
i. Was that instructed by Rosemary and Della?
ii. Is this your privilege as a solicitor to harass me on my blog posts that have no relevance to your client?
Mr. Cham, the original development plan was approved by the approving authorities (DBKK). Were the alterations made instructed by the Appropriate Authorities?
Mr. Cham, the rules above clearly state that no change or deviation from the approved plans shall be made without the consent in writing of the purchaser. Have you seen the consent from the purchasers?
To have a development plan approved by fabricating survey plans is a serious offence.
33.
To:nasri@audit.gov.my
Cc:halimuddin@audit.gov.my,azizahdaud@audit.gov.my,jimmy@audit.gov.my,asmah@audit.gov.my
Thu, 2 Feb 2023 at 09:19
Tuan,
I wrote an email to you dated 24.11.2022 and have yet to receive a response.
Subsequent to my email I have discovered that a fraudulent as-built survey and amended development plan were submitted to obtain occupancy certificates.
I hope you will look into this before the developer commences phase 2 and 3 of the project.
34.
Email to CM Datuk Hajiji
To:HajijiNoor@sabah.gov.my
Cc:jacinta.yapp@sabah.gov.my
Mon, 20 Feb 2023 at 09:58
Dear YAB Datuk Seri Panglima Haji Hajiji.
I sent you two emails via Datuk Dr. Roland Chia dated 23.12.2022 and again on 25.12.2022. I am sending this to your email address as I have yet to receive an acknowledgment from Datuk Dr. Roland Chia.
I am writing to you after attempting, for 3 years, to solve the problems faced by residents of Vistana Heights, Ira Manis.
Until now, we have not moved in because we are unable to drive up the driveway. We want this resolved immediately.
YAB Datuk, I complained to the developer, the engineers, the architect, DBKK and finally to LPPB to no avail.
I then wrote to YB. Datuk Masidi, our minister in charge of Housing, who asked me to write to the Permanent Secretary YB Datuk Jamili Nais.
In addition to writing to YB Datuk Jamili Nais I also wrote to the Permanent Secretary of MOF Datuk Mohd Sofian Alfian Nair as he is one of the four ex-officio members of LPPB.
DBKK approved the development plan based on falsified as-built survey plans by the surveyor, Jurukur Terra Firma and fabricated amended development plan by the architect, Arkitek LYS. The consultant engineers, Zaidun Leeng (Sabah) Sdn. Bhd also has a hand in this scheme.
YAB. Datuk, many of the house owners are unable to drive up the driveway as the driveway is too steep and not in accordance with the Original Development Plan approved by DBKK.
Two of the house owners have extended the driveway onto the road which should be considered illegal as they are a road hazard. What has DBKK done about this illegal extension despite complaints from the developer?
35.
Email to Mayor;
To:mayor@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Thu, 23 Feb 2023 at 08:31
Dear Datuk Mayor,
I wrote to you about the steep driveway to my son's house (S9, Lot 15) at Vistana Heights, Ira Manis (refer to my email below forwarded to you at the request of your PA on 8.9.2022.)
This morning, 23.2.2023, I saw another extension of the driveway by more than one foot of another house.
Please let me know if there are new laws that allow house owners to extend their driveways onto the road.
I understand that the developer had complained to DBKK and the officers had inspected the driveways and have not taken any action.
Attached, please find two photos of two different houses with extended driveways.
36.
Email to Datuk Bernard of JTU.
To:jtu@sabah.gov.my
Sun, 26 Feb 2023 at 16:57
Dear Datuk,
On 15.12.2022 I went to LJS and handed over a complaint about a surveyor who had fabricated the survey drawings to aid in the obtaining of OC for the developers of Vistana Heights, Ira Manis.
After two months, on 14.2.2023 I telephoned Ms. Fung, the CEO of LJS, and enquired about my complaint.
I was told that they have yet to hold a meeting.
Datuk, please let me know to whom I may escalate this matter to get a speedy response.
37.
Email from LJS
From:ljsabah@gmail.com
To:luqman michel,Dzulkarnain
Thu, 2 Mar 2023 at 12:31
Dear Sir,
This is to inform that a meeting was held on 21/2/2023 to look into your complaint.
Please be informed that we have written to the surveyor concerned requesting him to provide explanations and to submit all the details of the as-built survey carried out including documents and survey plans for the Board's further action.
38.
Email to Mr. Stanley Chong
To:Stanley.Chong@sabah.gov.my
Cc:mayor@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,aduan.lppb@sabah.gov.my,jtu@sabah.gov.my,ljsabah@gmail.com,eims@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Mon, 27 Mar 2023 at 06:53
Dear Mr. Stanley Chong,
I hope to receive the minutes of the meeting held on 10.3.2023 soon.
39.
Email to LJS
To:Lembaga Juruukur Sabah (Sabah Surveyors Board)
Wed, 9 Aug 2023 at 11:13
Dear Ms. Fung Yun Ling,
Your Board members made a site visit on 28.6.23.
I would be grateful if you could please forward me the survey drawing based on the survey points taken.
I would like to compare them with the survey points taken by a survey technician.
40.
Email to LJS
To:Lembaga Juruukur Sabah (Sabah Surveyors Board)
Cc:zawani@lam.gov.my,flora.takom@sabah.gov.my,mayor@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,stanley.chong@sabah.gov.my
Mon, 18 Mar 2024 at 17:41
Dear Miss. Fung Yun Ling,
On 28.6.23, after several requests, you came to Vistana Heights and inspected the road level and house platform. Licensed surveyors surveyed the road level and the house platform level in the presence of several board members of LJS.
I was promised to be given a survey report, and you have not produced one to date.
Today, I received an email from Lembaga Arkitek Malaysia asking for a survey report.
I have asked them to obtain a copy from your office as that would be the most practical thing to do.
Please extend me a copy of the survey you carried out on 28.6.23.
41.
Email to Mr.stanley Chong
To:stanley.chong@sabah.gov.my,aduan.lppb@sabah.gov.my
Cc:Rosemary.Ahping@Sabah.gov.my,Mayor@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,julian.joseph@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,practice@pam.org.my,arkiteklys@gmail.com,Della.Sinidol@Sabah.gov.my,drolandchia@gmail.com,jtu@sabah.gov.my,Jamali.Nais@sabah.gov.my,ljsabah@gmail.com
Mon, 5 Aug 2024 at 09:26
Dear Mr. Stanley Chong,
Recently I see building works being carried out in the next phase of Vistana Heights.
Is the work being carried out with the permission of the Ministry of Local Government and Housing?
My complaint to the Ministry of Local Government and Housing has yet to be resolved.
I have done everything I can to have this matter resolved amicably. I am left with no choice other than to complain to MACC.
I hope to receive a reply within 2 weeks before I hand over this matter to MACC.
42.
Letter/ email from LJS
From:ljsabah@gmail.com
To:luqman michel
Wed 15 Jan at 16:16
Dear Sir,
We attached the Board's letter LJS. 20 Vol. I/70 for information.
“Please be informed that the board is till looking into your complaint about the as-built survey plans for the Taman Puncak Vistana Heights, Ira Manis due to further verifications from the authority.”
43.
Email to LJS
To:Lembaga Juruukur Sabah (Sabah Surveyors Board)
Wed 15 Jan at 17:03
Dear Miss Fung,
I don't understand what further verification you require from which authority.
44.
Email to LJS
To:Lembaga Juruukur Sabah (Sabah Surveyors Board)
Cc:julian.joseph@sabah.gov.my,stanley.chong@sabah.gov.my,aduan.lppb@sabah.gov.my,mayor@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,practice@pam.org.my
Mon 20 Jan at 08:43
Dear En. S. Dzulkarnain S. Abdillah,
On 15.12.2022, I complained about the fabricated As-built survey plan for Taman Puncak Vistana.
This was followed up with several emails to and from LJS/me, and is attached below.
How is it that the Board is still looking into this complaint after over two years?
What further verification do you need and from which authority?
I demand a reply within one month of the date of this email as this is the last of the information I require before proceeding with legal action.
45.
Email to YB Datuk Shafie Apdal
To:shafieapdal@yahoo.com,shafie.apdal@outlook.com
Wed 5 Feb at 03:47
Dear YB Datuk Shafie,
On 15.1.2025, I received an email from Lembaga Juruukur Sabah which states the following.
'Please be informed that the Board is still looking into your complaint about the As-built survey plans for
Taman Puncak Vistana, Iramanis due to further verification from the authority.'
The occupancy Certificate was obtained by submitting a fabricated as-built survey plan to DBKK.
This project was approved during your term as Chief Minister.
Can you shed some light on who is the authority that LJS is waiting to verify?
My son bought a house and it has been vacant since the OC was issued in 2019.
46.
Email to Integrity Department
To:SitiFairuz.Hussin@sabah.gov.my,admin.uins@sabah.gov.my
Tue 11 Feb at 08:22
Puan, Siti Fairuz,
I believe many Government Departments are involved in this scheme.
Here is my complaint about LJS, one of the culprits in this scheme.
I will collate the information of the others in later emails.
47.
Email to LPPB
To:Suzilawati.MSha@sabah.gov.my
Cc:Rabiatul.Abdullah@sabah.gov.my
Thu 17 Apr at 06:20
Dear Puan Suzi,
I have not received any acknowledgment of receipt of my emails, as requested by me and agreed upon by you.
This matter, which involves many civil servants, could have been easily resolved since I started complaining 4 years ago.
Don't let this become like the Malay proverb 'Nasi sudah jadi bubur'.
I request you to make an appointment for me with Datuk Masiung.
Please let me know when we may be able to meet him.
48*
Email to DBKK
To:tantinny.fung@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Cc:julian.joseph@sabah.gov.my
Fri 25 Apr at 12:10
Dear Puan Tantinny Fung,
I refer to my email dated 6.10.2022 and several other emails to you subsequently.
I was informed by your staff then that the development plan for Vistana Heights which was extended to me S/1045/ii/63 dated 1995 was the only development plan for the Vistana Heights project.
On a complaint about the architect, Lembaga Arkitek Malaysia extended me a copy of a development plan dated August 2018.
The S&P was signed on 13.1.2014 and a development plan was attached to the S&P.
I would be grateful if you would kindly extend me a copy of the development plan dated on or before 13.1.2014.
Kindly inform me when I may go to your office to pay you the fee and collect the plan.
49*
Second request - Development plan for Vistana Heights - Ira Manis
To:tantinny.fung@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Cc:julian.joseph@sabah.gov.my
Tue 29 Apr at 09:41
Dear Puan Tantinny,
I refer to my email dated 25.4.2025, below.
I have to present the case to the court before 2.10.25, and as such, this matter is urgent.
I would be grateful if you could kindly extend me the Development plan dated on or before
13.1.2014, as that was the date my son Faisal Luqman signed the S&P agreement.
A copy of the development plan was attached to the S&P.
Please inform me when I may go to your office and make the necessary payment, and collect the development plan.
50.
Email from JMG
Dear Sir,
Thank you for your follow-up email dated 6 February 2023 regarding your concerns about the stability of the hill at Vistana Heights.
2. The most critical and urgent step is to determine the actual site and slope conditions through a professional slope stability assessment. This assessment should be carried out by a qualified geologist and/or geotechnical engineer. The typical process involves the following steps:
i) Engage Geological Consulting Firms to conduct a geological study and perform kinematic analysis if the slope is composed of rock.
ii) Engage Geotechnical Consulting Firms to carry out slope stability analysis (including determination of the Factor of Safety) if the slope is composed of soil.
iii) Conduct a Soil Investigation, which may involve drilling boreholes, performing Standard Penetration Tests (SPT), collecting soil samples, and conducting laboratory tests to determine the engineering properties of the soil.
Ketua Penolong Pengarah
51.*
Email to Architect LYS
To:arkiteklys@gmail.com
Tue 6 May at 01:33
Dear Ar. Lee Yik Soon,
Following Tuan Lifred's request from DBKK yesterday, could you kindly let me know when I can collect the Development Plan attached to the S&P? I will settle the required fee upon collection.
52.*
Email to Sr. Lifred Wong
To:MALISSA BINTI SAMIN
Cc:LINA BINTI MOHD. AMIN
Wed 14 May at 04:18
Dear Mr. Lifred,
I collected the 2007 DP from LYS Sdn. Bhd. yesterday. If this is the DP linked to my son’s S&P, it appears to be falsified, much like the 2018 final DP. This suggests all DPs are compromised, and the as-built survey is fabricated.
I kindly request an urgent one-on-one meeting to discuss this matter at your earliest convenience.
53.
To:Lembaga Juruukur Sabah (Sabah Surveyors Board)
Cc:julian.joseph@sabah.gov.my,stanley.chong@sabah.gov.my,aduan.lppb@sabah.gov.my,mayor@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,practice@pam.org.my
Fri 16 May at 14:26
Dear Ms. Fung Yun Ling,
I am still waiting for your 'investigation' to be completed.
I was informed by the DBKK Pengarah that DBKK is not the authority you wrote about.
Can you please let me know which authority you are referring to?
54.
Email to Integrity Department
To:SITI FAIRUZ BINTI AG MOHD HUSSIN
Thu 12 Jun at 07:01
Dear Puan Siti Fairuz,
I attended a meeting yesterday organised by DBKK where 2 officers from Integrity Department attended.
DBKK never addressed several questions I had raised.
The one single question on the driveway was misled by using wrong data.
I plead with you to get LJS to forward the spot level survey done in June 2023.
I would be grateful if I could meet with your officers with documents to explain the situation.
55.
Email to Integrity Department
To:SITI FAIRUZ BINTI AG MOHD HUSSIN
Tue 17 Jun at 04:05
Good morning, Puan Siti Fairuz,
Thank you for your email dated June 16, 2025.
I obtained the as-built survey for Vistana Heights from DBKK on November 15, 2022, and received a duplicate from LAM on March 21, 2023. I presented this copy to Mr. Lifred Wong during the DBKK meeting on June 11, 2025, and Mr. Rayner from DBKK confirmed it matched his records.
The minutes from the May 5, 2025 meeting indicate a 2.76 ft difference between the platform height of Lot S9 and the interpolated road height from the 2018 development plan. When Mr. Lifred asked if I agreed with this figure, I stated the height difference exceeds 4 feet. At the June 11, 2025 meeting, Mr. Lifred referenced a height of 31.05m (101.87 ft), resulting in a 4.38 ft difference (106.25 – 101.87). I disputed the figure 31.05m as it does not appear on the as-built survey. I continue to question whether the as-built survey was altered to secure the Occupancy Certificate.
Further questions I have raised with Mr. Lifred, which remain unanswered, are as follows:
i. The Development Plans (DPs) dated 1995, 2007 (approved in 2011), and 2018 indicate a 9-foot drainage reserve behind houses D18 (previously S1) to D17 (previously S18). However, this drainage reserve does not exist on-site.
ii. The As-Built Survey (ABS) also depicts this non-existent drainage reserve. An ABS should accurately reflect the actual site conditions.
iii. The ABS shows the boundary of the back wall of unit S8 as shorter than that of S9, with units S7 to S3 being even shorter than S8. This difference is not reflected in any of the DPs, including the latest DP dated 2018.
56.
Email to JPA
To:wdahlan@jpa.gov.my,marziana.malik@jpa.gov.my
Cc:sitifairuz.hussin@sabah.gov.my
Mon 30 Jun at 05:29
Dear Tan Sri Wan Ahmad Dahlan Abdul Aziz,
I hope this message finds you well. I am writing with reference to a report in The Star dated 10 June 2025, which outlined the prohibition on public officers making statements that could potentially embarrass or tarnish the government’s reputation, as well as restrictions on disclosing factual information related to government operations. I fully respect and appreciate the intent behind these guidelines.
I am reaching out to seek your guidance on a matter concerning a property I am maintaining, purchased by my son, for which the occupancy certificate was issued in October 2019. Unfortunately, there are significant issues with the property that have yet to be resolved despite my best efforts to address them amicably.
The driveway to the house is excessively steep and poses safety concerns, as it does not comply with the specifications outlined in the Sales and Purchase Agreement or the original development plan. Additionally, a retaining wall, promised by the developer and mandated by the Dewan Bandaraya Kota Kinabalu (DBKK), has not been constructed, rendering the house unfit for occupancy. Despite my repeated requests to the developer and architect to rectify the driveway gradient and construct the mandated retaining wall, no progress has been made.
In December 2022, I lodged a complaint with the Lembaga Juruukur Sabah (LJS) regarding the as-built survey plan, which I believe was inaccurately prepared to obtain the occupancy certificate. On 28 June 2023, representatives from LJS, including surveyors and members of the Board of Directors, conducted a spot level survey at my residence in Vistana Heights. However, despite my requests, I have not yet received the survey report. A letter from LJS dated 15 January 2025 stated that the Board is still reviewing my complaint pending "further verification from the authority," but my inquiries about the identity of this authority remain unanswered.
Since 2022, I have been corresponding with DBKK to address these concerns but received no response until I escalated the matter to the Integrity Department in February 2025. A meeting was convened by the Director of DBKK on 5 May 2025, followed by another on 11 June 2025, attended by two officers from the Integrity Department. During the latter meeting, figures not present in the original as-built survey plan were presented to suggest compliance. However, my question regarding whether DBKK had mandated the construction of the retaining wall, as recorded in the minutes of the 5 May 2025 meeting, remains unanswered despite being assigned for action by DBKK’s engineer and town planner.
As the deadline for legal action approaches on 2 October 2025, I am eager to resolve this matter amicably. I have requested a meeting with the Integrity Department, but this has not yet been arranged.
Tan Sri, I would be deeply grateful for your guidance on how I might proceed to resolve these issues in a constructive and cooperative manner. Your advice would be invaluable in helping me navigate this situation.
Following is my article in the Daily Express yesterday.
57
Email to Mayor
To:mayor@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Cc:wdahlan@jpa.gov.my,marziana.malik@jpa.gov.my,sitifairuz.hussin@sabah.gov.my
Tue 1 Jul at 07:10
Dear Datuk Mayor,
I am writing to express my profound dissatisfaction with the ongoing issue of illegal driveway extensions onto public roads, a matter I first raised in February 2023.
Has DBKK sanctioned a new regulation permitting homeowners to extend driveways at their discretion?
58
To:mayor@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Cc:wdahlan@jpa.gov.my,marziana.malik@jpa.gov.my
Thu 10 Jul at 06:48
Dear YBhg. Dato’ Sri Dr. Haji Sabin Samitah,
I am writing to formally raise concerns about the lack of response from the Director General, Sr. Lifred Wong, to my two previous letters regarding landslide risks and structural issues in Vistana Heights. These concerns remain unaddressed, raising questions about transparency, accountability, and adherence to DBKK’s public service mandate. During meetings on May 5 and June 11, 2025, the Director General dismissed my concerns without providing evidence or a formal response. This is particularly troubling given DBKK’s commitment to transparency and its responsibility for urban planning, environmental protection, and infrastructure maintenance. The absence of written replies to my letters suggests potential procedural lapses or an unwillingness to engage with public inquiries.
59
Email to DBKK officers
To:kalvin@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,tantinny.fung@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,jack@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,saiman.angak@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,alexcius.likid@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,durie.juneh@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,dony.johanes@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,lilitia@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,beddu.ahmad@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,raynerricky.sedomon@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,julian.joseph@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Cc:manaf@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,zainuddin.abdgoyoh@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,esther.chongchiufung@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,salmah.batin@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,gloriediana.joseph@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,elezebeth.yadon@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,carey.paulin@dbkk.sabah.gov.my,salvia.yusop@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Thu 10 Jul at 07:03
Dear Sirs,
I have asked several times regarding a retaining wall behind the houses at Vistana Heights.
I have never received a reply in writing.
60
Email to Mr. Stanley Chong
To:stanley.chong@sabah.gov.my,mayor@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Cc:mudznah.yusof@sabah.gov.my,julian.joseph@sabah.gov.my,sitifairuz.hussin@sabah.gov.my
Tue 15 Jul at 10:52
Dear Mr. Stanley Chong,
I am writing to express my extreme dissatisfaction with the ongoing unresolved issues concerning Vistana Heights since 2022, despite my exhaustive efforts to seek a resolution. Your inaction and the apparent negligence of your office are unacceptable.
During our telephone conversation on February 16, 2023, you acknowledged the gravity of the situation, stating that if the occupancy certificate for Vistana Heights was obtained fraudulently, it constitutes a serious matter. I documented this discussion in an email sent the same day. Yet, no progress has been made.
61
Email to Datuk Abidin Madingkir
To:amy.tong@sabah.gov.my
Tue 15 Jul at 11:07
Dear YB Datuk Abidin Madingkir,
I am forwarding you an email I just sent to Mr.Stanley Chong and the current Mayor of DBKK.
The Vistana Heights project's development plan was approved by you in 2011.
The subsequent Development was prepared and submitted to DBKK in 2018 after the project was completed.
The plan was based on fabricated as-built survey. The 2018 Development Plan does not conform to the as-built survey plan and is different from the plan approved by you in 2011.
I am writing to you as a last resort before taking legal action against the developer, architect and DBKK for fraud.
62
Email to JPA
To:wdahlan@jpa.gov.my,marziana.malik@jpa.gov.my,salehuddin.dahlan@jpa.gov.my
Tue 15 Jul at 11:15
Dear Tan Sri Wan Ahmad Dahlan bin Haji Abdul Aziz,
I refer to my email dated 30.6.2025.
I am forwarding my email to Mr.Stanley Chong and the Mayor of Kota Kinabalu for your information and action.
63
Email to Integrity Department
To:sitifairuz.hussin@sabah.gov.my
Mon 21 Jul at 15:56
Dear Puan Siti Fairuz,
The minutes of meeting for 11.6.2025 states that you said that the complaint to BIGONS is closed.
Neither my wife Siti Mariam nor I remember you saying it.
On 20.6.2025 we spoke on the telephone where you said you will arrange for a meeting with your boss.
On that day you said nothing about BIGONS being closed.
64
Email to BIGONS
To:Sistem i-Adu 2.0
Mon 21 Jul at 16:00
Tuan/puan
Tolong beri tahu say bagaimana says boleh akses
akaun saya - BIGoNS/DBKK:600-01/0680/2025/KBU
65
Email to mayor
To:mayor@dbkk.sabah.gov.my
Cc:wdahlan@jpa.gov.my,marziana.malik@jpa.gov.my
Wed 23 Jul at 01:53
Subject: Request for Meeting to Discuss Concerns Regarding Vistana Heights Occupancy Certificate Approval
Dear Datuk Seri Dr. Haji Sabin Samitah,
I am writing to express my deep disappointment regarding an unresolved issue that appears to fall within the scope of your previous role as Director-General of the National Financial Crime Prevention Centre (NFCC) and your current position as Mayor of Kota Kinabalu City Hall (DBKK). Specifically, I am concerned about the approval of the Occupancy Certificate for Vistana Heights, despite allegations that the as-built survey and development plans submitted for this project were fabricated.
66
Email to Mr.Stanley Chong
To:STANLEY CHONG HON CHUNG
Fri 25 Jul at 06:17
Dear Mr. Stanley Chong,
I pray this email find you in the pink of health.
Please pass this email to Datuk Yeo Boon Hai as I don't have his email address.
Since 2022, I have repeatedly urged the developer of Vistana Heights to honor commitments made by the late Robert Lee and Jessy Lee to construct a retaining wall behind the residential units S1 to S18, (now renamed D17 to D18).
67
Email to mayor
To:pejabaymayor.dbkk@gmail.com
Cc:Viola.chin@sabah.gov.my
Mon 28 Jul at 09:36
Dear Datuk Seri Dr Samin Samitah,
I have written several emails to you at mayor@dbkk.sabah.my and had never received any response.
What your staff members are doing is detrimental to you and the Government of Sabah. They are misleading others to cover up their deceit in approving the occupancy certificate of Vistana Heights.
Since 2022 I have tried to resolve matters amicably to no avail.
Comments