Churn, Encroachment, and Illusion: Anatomy of an Ongoing Battle Against Litigation Churn and Fabricated Property Data
This is for educational purposes. This is not legal advice.
In civil litigation, clients go to lawyers for a resolution. They seek an end to a dispute, a fair settlement, or an honest assessment of their legal position. Unfortunately, a troubling subset of practitioners, in Sabah, operates on a completely different business model: churn, delay, and factual manufacture.
Instead of advising clients to mitigate risks or settle when the documentary evidence is overwhelmingly against them, some lawyers choose to prolong cases artificially. They manufacture meritless counterclaims, erect walls of denial, and churn billable hours—leaving their clients to foot massive legal bills for positions that are legally untenable.
When a legal defense shifts from interpreting law to manipulating foundational facts and masking severe structural defects, it crosses the line from zealous advocacy into an abuse of the court process.
1. The Manufactured Counterclaim: A Weapon of Distraction
When a rogue legal team faces a rock-solid claim supported by statutory authorities, their first line of defense is often an aggressive, groundless Counterclaim.
The strategy is simple: mudding the waters. By filing a massive, vexatious counterclaim, they attempt to intimidate the plaintiff and drain their financial resources. These counterclaims often attack the "locus standi" (the legal right to stand before a court) of the plaintiff’s representatives or family members—even when those family members hold absolute, written authorization to act. It is a classic procedural stalling tactic designed to distract the Court from the core issue.
2. Ignoring the Paper Trail
A prime example of litigation churn occurs when lawyers allow their clients to deny facts that are already permanently etched into public and statutory records.
3. Masking Defects with Unauthorized Open-Space Encroachment
Perhaps the most severe exposure of systemic developer fraud occurs when a developer actively executes unapproved site alterations to bypass dangerous design defects.
In severe topography developments, when a slope gradient is too steep to build a standard, usable driveway, rogue developers have been caught completely omitting driveways from original plans. To patch over the defect on the ground, they might annex massive swathes of land—such as over 20 feet of width stolen directly from adjacent municipal open spaces—to construct makeshift, unapproved access roads.
4. The Price Table Illusion: Fabricating Transaction Data
To escape liability for damages or to artificially deflate historical property values, rogue actors frequently present sub-sale particulars and pricing tables that are mathematical and chronological impossibilities.
The Ultimate Cost of Churn
When lawyers choose to validate and submit fabricated tables, ignore municipal open-space boundaries, and defend unapproved site modifications, they are not serving their clients. They are gambling with their clients' money and reputation.
Judges are trained to spot inconsistencies. When an artificial table faces an ironclad municipal record, an executed Sale and Purchase Agreement, or a previous sworn affidavit, the fabricated defense collapses. The rogue lawyers walk away with their heavily churned legal fees, while the clients are left to face the severe legal consequences of attempting to mislead the Court.
True legal professionalism lies in counseling clients toward truth, risk mitigation, and resolution—not spinning a web of manufactured data to keep a billable file open.
Because filing a fabricated pleading is an act of extreme bad faith, courts use financial penalties to punish the offenders:
• Indemnity Costs: The judge can order the Defendants to pay 100% of one’s actual legal expenses to punish them for forcing one to litigate a fabricated defense.
• Wasted Costs Orders Against the Lawyers: This is where the rogue lawyers' business model completely backfires. Under Order 59 Rule 6 of the Rules of Court 2012, if a lawyer files pleadings that they know contain fabrications, or fails to vet obvious falsehoods, the Court can order the lawyers to pay one’s legal costs out of their own pockets, or forbid them from collecting any fees from their own clients.

Comments